Interesting Article on Top 100 Women's Programs and NCAA Infractions

tycat947

Active member
Joined
Nov 6, 2008
Messages
5,238
Reaction score
8
Interesting article from writer in Atlanta from November 2012 on his rating of the Top 100 Division 1 Women's Basketball programs. He follows the Atlanta Dream of the WNBA and the Georgia Tech women's basketball team. Most people won't be shocked by his outsider rankings but some will. He also discusses the programs with NCAA infractions (past and present) and concerns of potential for ruining the women's basketball reputation as relatively scandal free.

http://www.swishappeal.com/2012/11/...tball-top-100-programs-recruiting-infractions

I apologize if this has already been posted. I had not seen before. There are also a lot of links to underlying stories.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like Muffett isn't a Mulkey fan either.

http://www.wndu.com/sports/headline...basketball-star-Skylar-Diggins-173794721.html

Muffet's Squad still not over the sting of national title loss


A new season has arrived for the Notre Dame women's basketball team.

Six months after appearing in the national championship game for the 2nd straight season, has Muffet's Squad gotten over the sting of losing to Baylor?

"No," Irish women's basketball coach Muffet McGraw said with a long pause Thursday at basketball Media Day. "We have not."

"I think for a lot of reasons, not the least of which was what happened after and what came out after, I think it made it harder to swallow," McGraw continued, referring to some minor NCAA violations against Baylor that came out a few weeks after the national title game. "We know we didn't play well and they were a team that unbeatable."

McGraw couldn't hold back the emotions after the loss last April, which resulted in the departures of three starters: Dev Peters, Natalie Novosel and Brittany Mallory.

So can the Irish make another run with the Big Three gone?

"Yes," McGraw explained. "We still have the Big 1 in Skylar."

Skylar Diggins returns for her final season under the Golden Dome. The South Bend Washington grad has been everything Notre Dame could have asked for. And Notre Dame has been everything Skylar could have asked for.

"It's the best decision I've ever made," Diggins explained. "When I came here, I knew that I was allowing Notre Dame to turn me into the woman I would be for the rest of my life. I love that woman that I'm becoming."

"To be able to keep my family in the loop and my relationship with mother is the most important thing. Letting her be involved and my family and the South Bend community which has been supporting me since I was small--following my career---they get to follow me here. It's been a great experience all around and one I'll remember forever and I get to play for a good team too."

But both Diggins and McGraw can't believe this is the final year.

"I feel like it was just yesterday that she came in as a freshman and she's had so many firsts and so many great moments," McGraw said. "She's done so many great things for our program. It's going to be a very difficult senior night--very emotional."

"I cannot," Skylar said with a big smile when asked if she can believe she's a senior. "The time has gone by so quickly. It's bittersweet for me because in one hand, I get to start this season and this is an exciting season with a new team, new challenges but on the other hand, this is my last year here at Notre Dame."

Diggins will take on a boatload of the responsibility this season as one of just two returning starters. The other returner is Kayla McBride who McGraw expects to be the team's leading scorer. Natalie Achonwa was a part-time starter last year but will be the force in the middle. Achonwa picked up a ton of experience in the summer when she played for Canada in the Olympics.

Notre Dame hosts Edinboro in an exhibition game on November 1st at 7pm at Purcell Pavilion. The regular season opener is against Ohio State in Charleston, S.C. aboard the USS Yorktown on November 8th with the the regular season home opener set for November 18th vs UMass at 2pm.

Notre Dame hosts Baylor in a rematch of the national championship game on December 5th at 7pm.
 
Also interesting is some of the factors of recruits choosing schools.

Interviews and models

There isn't much written about how basketball players decide on a school but a lot has been written about how football players decide. More than likely, this is because of greater fan interest and the greater financial potential of having a working model. There are a lot of differences between college football players and women's basketball players to say the least, but the football recruiting process might provide some insight.

Economists at Mercer University - Mike DuMond, Allen Lynch and Jennifer Platania - made the attempt to predict where highly ranked football players would sign. They built a predictive model that had a 71 percent success rate, based on the choices of approximately 3300 football players made between 2002 and 2004. A large array of factors was built into their model, and they could determine which of these factors had great predictive significance and which did not.

Factors NOT having great predictive significance were:

Graduation rate
Number of Bowl Championship Series (BCS) appearances
Roster depth at a recruited player's positions
Numbers of players who go on to the pros
Number of national championship victories
The last one is particularly surprising.

Factors having great predictive significance were:

Whether the athlete made an "official visit" to a specific college
Whether the school is in a BCS conference
The distance from the high school athlete’s hometown to a specific school
Whether the recruit is in the same state as a specific school
The final AP Ranking of a specific school in the previous year of competition
The number of conference titles a school has recorded in recent years
Whether the school is currently under a "bowl ban" for violating NCAA rules
The current number of scholarship reductions a school faces for violating NCAA rules
The size of the team’s stadium (measured in terms of seating capacity)
Whether the school has an on-campus stadium
The current age of the team’s stadium
Oddly enough, scholarship reductions were a positive factor, not a negative factor. Recruits knew that with reduced scholarships, there would be less competition for positions and playing time, so Baylor's reduction in scholarships might not hurt them that much.

If we had the data in women's basketball, we could attempt to do something similar. Unfortunately, gathering such data would be a volunteer effort like most things in women's basketball.
 
How DARE this bunch rate OU in the Top 10 of all D-1 women's programs??? I sometimes get the feeling on this board that OU is in a death-spiral.
 
How DARE this bunch rate OU in the Top 10 of all D-1 women's programs??? I sometimes get the feeling on this board that OU is in a death-spiral.

I think just about everyone on this board would say OU is a top 10 program based upon the number of wins and trips to the final four. As the article said, recruiting will determine if OU stays in the top 10.
 
I think just about everyone on this board would say OU is a top 10 program based upon the number of wins and trips to the final four. As the article said, recruiting will determine if OU stays in the top 10.
Well, isn't that true for every program in the top 10?
 
Back
Top