Rick Reilly destroys Jimmer

thebigabd

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 31, 2008
Messages
13,496
Reaction score
77
NEW ORLEANS -- So that's the end of Jimmermania. Saw it for myself. Caught the closing act. Not impressed.

Thanks to one of the worst performances of Jimmer Fredette's frabulous career -- and a set of teammates who looked like pizza delivery guys -- the BYU star took a hard fall in the Big Easy. BYU was bumped out of the Sweet Sixteen on Thursday, losing to Florida in a lopsided overtime, 83-74.

You can take off those "Romney-Fredette in 2012" T-shirts now.

Except for a stretch in the middle, when he was brilliant, Fredette was brutal.

Yes, he scored 32 points, but he took 29 shots to do it. He seemed to be wearing a blindfold from the 3-point arc -- 3-for-15. Plus, he committed six turnovers and wandered aimlessly through the lane on defense like Moses in the desert. I've seen dead people play better defense. At least they occasionally trip people.

If his last college game is what he's bringing to the NBA, then I'd say, in five years, he's got a really good chance to be your Provo area Isuzu dealer.

Great kid, though. Polite, smart (good chess player, whiz at Sudoku), studies his Bible in hotel rooms. Maybe that was the problem. Fredette and the largely Mormon BYU Nation should've never been made to come to New Orleans. You can sin just by osmosis here.

You should have seen some of them on Bourbon Street, the freshly scrubbed Cougars fans, horrified to find themselves among the window strippers, the hurricane chuggers and the bead catchers.

Then again, some of the comparisons BYU fans were making about The Jimmer this week made you think they deserved it.

"He's a little Maravich," a guy in a BYU shirt told me.

No! No, he isn't! He's not within a mile of Mardi Gras floats of Maravich. Maravich could get his shot off from the bottom of a swimming pool. He could get 40 in handcuffs. He averaged 44 points a game in college (to Fredette's 28 this season) and that's without the 3-point shot. With it, studies of his game film have shown, he would have averaged over 55.

"He's better than Danny Ainge was," a lady in a Cougars sweatshirt told me.

No! No, he isn't! Ainge was Danny Clutch (remember his Sweet 16 drive in 1981) Fredette didn't have a single game-winning shot all year. Against Florida, he didn't score a single point in the game's final eight minutes, or, for that matter, the first 13.

"I know from just watching him he's going to be a great NBA player," Oklahoma City Thunder point guard Russell Westbrook said.

No! No, he isn't!

Don't get me wrong. The Jimmer will make a modest living in the NBA. When he gets hot, he can drain them from the hotel coffee shop. He splits the double team as well as anybody in the league right now and he has a whole Santa bag of off-balance scoop shots with either hand. But until he shows more interest in defense than a blind man has in rainbows, he's going to spend most of his NBA life sitting on padded folding chairs.

To his credit, he'll have more help in the NBA than he had this season at BYU. His best rebounder, Brandon Davies, was thrown off the team for violating BYU's no-booze, no-sex, no-caffeine honor code, which meant it was pretty much Jimmer or nothing against the tall trees of Florida. He never came out once in the first 44 minutes and had to fire up shots through the tiniest cracks of light allowed to him by the Gators. He wore out. He fired up two 3s from at least six feet behind the arc in the overtime and missed them both, badly. Then again, he had a cut in his chin that looked like something George Foreman had left and his calf was killing him. But when his teammates really needed him, at the end of regulation, on defense, Jimmer really hit the dimmer.

Florida missed a trey with 24 seconds to go and Fredette's man, Erving Walker, who stands only 5-6, beat him to the long rebound. It wasn't hard. Fredette was nowhere to be found. I'm not even sure Fredette knew who his man was the entire night. Florida wound up with a reset and the last shot.

"If we'd have gotten it, we'd have had about eight seconds left differential," Fredette said. "I'd have had the ball in my hands at the end."

Note to Jimmer: To get the ball, one must occasionally check one's man and/or box said man out. One did neither.

"The weird thing is, [his defense] has gotten progressively worse over the year," says Fredette's own teammate, Nick Martineau. "From the start, he's never really been accountable to it, but it's just gotten looser as the year's gone on. But he can play defense. He really can. He'll definitely tighten it up for the NBA."

He'd better.

"I just want to take a couple weeks off and then start getting ready to try to make an NBA team," said the man who probably will be voted about five player of the year awards. "That's my dream, to make an NBA team."

Fine. That he can do. But you think this barely 6-2 kid with no speed and YMCA hops can be the next Maravich or Ainge or Westbrook?

Fredette about it.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=6257636
 
I remember when Rick Reilly was funny and wrote good stuff.

He admits this is his first real Jimmer experience. What a clown.
 
I'm so old, I can remember when Rick Reilly was an interesting and relevant columnist.
 
I'm certainly no Jimmer fan, but This is kind of a moronic article. You're refuting statements made by random fans in BYU gear? Also the "Mormons in shock in New Orleans" reference is tired and unoriginal.

That being said, we ran into Rick Reilly in New Orleans before the Sugar Bowl in 03 and he was a cool dude. We were drunk as hell and probably just as annoying but he took the time to talk to us for a bit. Maybe he was drunk as hell too.
 
that being said, we ran into rick reilly in new orleans before the sugar bowl in 03 and he was a cool dude. We were drunk as hell and probably just as annoying but he took the time to talk to us for a bit. Maybe he was drunk as hell too.


tiger bait!!!
 
he basis this on only one game, and he knows more than the BYU fanbase about him that followed his whole career. Pompous arrogant idiot writer!
 
he basis this on only one game, and he knows more than the BYU fanbase about him that followed his whole career. Pompous arrogant idiot writer!

Yep. Write a scathing article after watching only one game. Makes a lot of sense.

I'm not a huge fan of the BYU offense that game. I didn't watch enough BYU to know if they played that way all year or not. Having one guy dribble the ball 60% of every possession isn't great offense.
 
I don't think he is wrong. He is comparing Jimmer to three great, proven players. There aren't many players ever that compare to what Pistol Pete did in college. Jimmer is obviously a great college basketball player, but nobody knows how his game will translate to the next level.
 
I don't think he is wrong. He is comparing Jimmer to three great, proven players. There aren't many players ever that compare to what Pistol Pete did in college. Jimmer is obviously a great college basketball player, but nobody knows how his game will translate to the next level.

What's wrong is writing that piece after having seen a player in only one game.
 
WHY do people even ever bring up Maravich?

NO ONE is like Pistol Pete. NO ONE.

You don't rag on a guy because he isn't like the greatest shooter in the history of the game.

Next I'm gonna go in and slap my wife "You're not Jennifer Anniston!"
 
"I know from just watching him he's going to be a great NBA player," Oklahoma City Thunder point guard Russell Westbrook said.

No! No, he isn't!

Yes, Rick Reilly is a better authority on who will and won't make it in the NBA than a player who has made it in the NBA.
 
WHY do people even ever bring up Maravich?

NO ONE is like Pistol Pete. NO ONE.

You don't rag on a guy because he isn't like the greatest shooter in the history of the game.

Next I'm gonna go in and slap my wife "You're not Jennifer Anniston!"
At least your wife can keep a man...........

I looked at him play twice this season, both in the tournament. I can't disagree with much of what Reilly said. Some of the comparisons relative to all time greats were, however, over the top. Nevertheless, after I watched him twice on TV, I thought that he might struggle in the NBA. He is though a very fine college player.

Reilly just criticized a kid who has garnered much national attention and adulation; how dare that he do that.
 
A more apt comparison would be JJ Red****. Fredd's NBA career would be very successful if he could as far as the most overhyped college player of the 2000's.
 
Reilly just criticized a kid who has garnered much national attention and adulation; how dare that he do that.

I don't have a problem with him criticizing the jimmer. He has done many things that deserve criticism.

My issue is anytime someone can shoot the dumbazzes bring up Pistol Pete in comparison. You don't compare just any good shooter to Pistol Pete. It's ignorant.
 
Back
Top