Smash Williams
New member
- Joined
- Jan 16, 2009
- Messages
- 1,753
- Reaction score
- 0
Dirk in his prime was an MVP, so of course prime Dirk was elite, but that's a pretty damn high cutoff for "elite."Not to mention that his team is not void of any talent. They have Pekovic, Rubio, Kevin Martin, Corey Brewer, JJ Barea... Those are decent pieces to have around an elite guy.
Let's take a guy we know is elite, in his prime. Would this be a playoff team:
PG: Ricky Rubio
SG: Kevin Martin
SF: Corey Brewer
PF: Dirk Nowtizki
C: Nikola Pekovic
Regardless of stats, numbers, etc... With Dirk in his prime, as an elite player, could he win with that supporting cast?
How many guys in their primes right now would have made Minnesota a playoff team if you swapped Love out for them? LeBron, KD...and that's probably it. Blake Griffin isn't winning 50 games with that team. Aldridge couldn't get back to the playoffs until Lillard blossomed into Portland's second star. If you want to look players at other positions, that's a bit harder, but I'm not buying someone like CP3 or Steph Curry transforming them into a 50-win team either.
If you want to define elite as "single-handedly carries any team to the playoffs in either conference," there are only two elite players in the league. Either way, Love is probably a Top 10 player, and Top 15 at bare minimum.