I mean I'm all for ripping Digger Phelps for saying OSU was going to play in the title game. That's just laughable. But no one has any clue what teams will make a run at any given time, or what teams will get in foul trouble in a game, or what teams will suddenly hit 45% of their threes, etc.
Basketball is an unpredictable game and that's what makes the NCAA tournament as good as it gets. Why bash people for giving their educated opinions? Who cares? It's TV for ratings.