Just to be clear, I actually like our talent/experience level more than oSu's and would pick us to be a better team this season.
M'Baye-Nash = Probably a push. M'Baye more experienced. I'd have to rely on guys that have seen more of M'Baye than highlight reels because athletically its a push if not advantage M'Baye. I'm really looking forward to this match-up.
I would take Nash's 1 year experience in the Big 12 over M'Baye's 2 years at Wyoming. I also like Nash's 13.3 points and 5 rebounds over M'Bayes 12 points and 5.7 rebounds, considering the league each played in.
Pledger-Brown = Totally different players, but I'd say Pledge. I'll take his range over Brown's athleticism.
I like Brown's defense, rebounding and scoring over Pledgers shooting. IMO Brown is OSU's best player.
Grooms-Smart = Talent edge to Smart for sure, but Grooms not bad except for shot, I'll say that Smart is better though based on the talent but Grooms put together a pretty okay season last year.
I agree with you here. I really liked Grooms (outside of his terrible shot)
Cobbins-Osby = Osby in a landslide barring significant improvement.
Osby is a better player. I think Cobbins has a chance to be much improved this year but he isn't quite on Osby's level yet.
Not sure what oSu would throw out as far as the fifth guy in their rotation, but you are probably comparing them to either Cam or Fitz. That is what makes oSu a confusing team to me., but I'd probably take Cam or Fitz over the candidates oSu is putting out there.