Newell - 20
Blair - 15
Neal - 13
Washington - 12
Those are the average minutes played for those guys. Significantly more than 8. And those are the minutes that the frosh have a chance to steal. That, and 3-5 from Clark, along with 1-2 from Pledger. There are plenty of minutes out there that don't have to be taken from the starters.
M'Baye over Washington and Arent. Bennett over Arent and Honore. The frosh over Newell/Blair/Neal. The frosh taking 5 minutes from Clark.
That is a TON of playing time, without sitting a guy like Pledger on the bench. Pledger averaged 33 minutes/game last year. I'd be shocked if he averaged less than 30 this year.
Here is the problem. You keep thinking in terms of "returning starters". Since you chose to box yourself in like that, I can see how you can come up with all these make believe rotations.
But, here is the reality. Coming off last season and starting his 2nd season, returning starter is not in Kruger's vocabulary. He said it isn't. He told his players it doesn't apply. Even Yo Yo said it. Returning starter is a figment of your imagination.
Kruger has never said that he needed a sronger bench to win. He said he needed better players, tougher players, players with more fight. From the way you shape your position, it is like you believe that Kruger thinks that Pledger is some special talent that he intends to shape his team around. It is just as likely that Kruger thinks just the opposite. That he is more than ready to move on to a player that isn't so limited in the ways that they contribute.
When the CBS guy picked OU as his Big 12 sleeper because he thought that Kruger might sart 2 talented freshmen, did he just make that up or did he have a source in the program. Don't they call him Mr. inside college basketball?
Yo Yo didn't have to say anything about starters or who would play. But, he did. He said that those freshmen have a chance to start every game as long as they are with the program. Is he making up stuff too?
You are putting way too much value in kids that can not win games and the Coach has publically question their heart. There is nothing a Coach could do that would more damning and reflective of his feelings. It would be a mistake to completly dismiss the possibility that Kruger is more than ready to just move on with his team.
I don't know who will step up and who won't. But, it isn't a complicated formula. If Kruger's best options look about like last years team with the same bunch getting simular minutes, the team will have a pretty low ceiling. If it is M'baye and Osby getting the 30+ min. and Fitz and Pledger capped at about 15 min, Kruger will have a pretty good bunch and a chance to go along ways.
I am not saying that Kruger would start or put in players just because they are different. They would have to step up. But, I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if Kruger didn't tell Cousins that the starting job was his to lose and that Heild turns out to be good enough to be that new direction guy.