Does seeding matter at all?
It's easy to say that he's 1-4 or whatever, but two of his trips were as 8/9 seeds, which are basically toss-ups every year. He won one and lost the other. Of course, in the year that he won, he was up against #1 seed Pitt in the second round, so advancing beyond that was going to be a stretch.
As for last year, people can say that we underachieved, but 5/12 games are also basically toss-ups at this point, especially when you're matched against one of the most ridiculously under-seeded teams in years and have to play them in their back yard.
Any more, if you're not a top 4 seed, you can almost forget about the seeding, because just about every game is a toss-up.