I would rather have CG, but it may be better for Capel's fortunes if he got a Juco PG (assuming he has some talent, of course) because there is a better chance the guy would get acclimated and contribute earlier. Next season could be Capel's last stand, and he really doesn't have time to wait on a Freshman to figure it out.
That said, I want CG because he'd be here 4 years, with or without Capel. I'm sick and tired of OU being so young and inexperienced all the time. We are always waiting for next year so we'll have some experience, and then we lose key players and are back to square one.