Glad someone finally pointed this out. It's an honest mistake, but I was tired of seeing it brought up as a contributing factor to the problems of that team.
I usually lurk rather than post, but here is my take on that team and their dynamics. You have three highly regarded guys who were pretty heavily recruited, although some of thr blue bloods were absent during the process, which probably should have raised a few more flags.
In Willie you had a very talented offensive player with a sizable ego and some maturity issues. His ego flared up from time to time his freshman year, but besides the Austin situation, was managed most of the time due to stronger leadership from upperclassmen and the presence of a player (Blake) that was undeniably a superior talent. I always figured that having a player that Willie couldn't realistically claim he was better than kept him in check, which was also needed to get the most out of him. After Blake and the leaders on that team left, I'm guessing Willie expected, and was probably told, that the team was his. IE: He'd be the Alpha of the team.
Enter TMG and Tiny.
In TMG, you had a guy with tremendous individual/1-on-1 talent. Some of the best I've seen around/at OU. Unfortunately, it also turns out he also had a tremendous attitude problem and a chip on his shoulder. Unlike Willie, I don't believe that TMG could be kept in check. Not by coaches or by other players. I know a lot of people characterize him as a bad person, (which I won't do because I don't know him) but I speculated it was more likely that he was just the type of kid that figured it's better to get his and do what he wants rather than allow anyone to tell him what to do. Anyone who got in the way of his thoughts/goals was just holding him down and therefore didn't matter. Despite his talent, it's easy to see that he probably shouldn't have been at OU because his mindset/attitude/stubbornness/lack of effort/whatever you want to call it disrupted the dynamics because he didn't have any intention of bowing down to Willie and was capable of leading other people down the same path as him. When you mix that kind of an attitude with the ability to get others to follow you, then that's a recipe for disaster on a young team.
Which brings me to Tiny. I believe Tiny had a ton of potential and talent. I think the problem with Tiny was that he was a big, imposing kid who looked the part of an alpha, but was really just a beta. Ultimately, I think Tiny was a good kid, but he lacked the maturity and guidance needed to keep him working hard and out of trouble. I'm guessing his history/background with TMG made it easy for him to follow TMG's lead, which hurt himself and the team. I thibk when things started going bad, he just did what he knew to do and went with tge flow. Like others here, I'm certain my not happy about the loan sutuation, but I don't really fault the kid either. Yes, it was wrong but I'm guessing he's not the first or the last to skirt the rules at the advice of someone he looked to for guidance (Oronde.) I think if he could have stuck around, he could have grown as a player and person and contributed to the team in a positive way. I think the voice of TMG and the addition of the investigation were just too much for him to overcome.
In the end, I think Willie was a talented kid who wasn't mature enough or strong enough to handle the leadership role he was handed/given. I don't think he was equipped to handle the challenges TMG introduced and I think the injuries were enough to convince him he shouldn't stick around OU any longer even though it probably would have done him good.
TMG was extremely talented, but couldn't be controlled. He was leaving one way or another and son he didn't care what was happening in the season.
Tiny was also very talented and I think he was a good kid that just got caught up in TMG's stuff. I think if he and Willie could or would have stuck around the program would have recovered and Tiny would have really flourished. But the investigation, regardless of how much he knew, sealed his fate.
On paper, that team was one of the most talented to hit the floor at the LNC, but having a young team with multiple egos, no true leader, and a sense of entitlement due to the program's recent success is too much to overcome.