All star games in all sports are pretty dumb. As long as they mean nothing then that is about as much as you should expect to get from them. Letting fans choose something is dumb because fans are dumb, just like Jefferson and Washington didn't write that every person in the US could vote because people are dumb. But we pay the bills so you got to give us a piece of the pie. Unfortunately player selection for all-star games are like life, not necessarily fair. In a cool world Blake would be in the game easily, but when you wake up from your cool dreams to your crappy life that is all the example you need that nobody ever asked you what you wanted, you just get something and either deal with it or whine. You must change your life.