I appreciate disagreement when it is so cogently stated.I normally agree w you syb. but not here..
Gioya is bigger faster stronger than dungee w/ more exp. She is the better player right now. Though Gioya does have a tendency to make some mistakes...
What i have noticed is though, some of Gioyas better games really take the ball out of Maddies hands. And while we need Gioya to be there to score and hit big shots, while being a very physical attacker- Maddie makes the right play almost all the time. Who is more valuable offensively? I am still not sure, and that is a problem. Maddie opens the door for Gioya because she can be so passive, otherwise I would say her ability to make everybody better while also having the ability, the skill set, and versatility to be one the top scorers is as valuable as any player around. Gioya on the other hand is physical and aggressive, and can shoot when she's hot, we have also seen her dominate the conference w/ pure scoring ability and a extreme confidence- but She definitely makes bad decisions, shoots really early in shot clocks, not looking to involve others most of the time and it definitely feels like its more her taking away from others, than anyone ever taking away from her. So the only answer I have is, who is ready to step up and be that player that can average 15-18 a game consistently, while cutting down on mistakes? We need that or were not going anywhere.
Peyton fits seamlessly w/ ether of the two, she happily takes wide open kicks, and also catches defenders off guard for a layup, I hardly even notice when she scores most of the time.
Vivi obviouly relies on whoever will throw her the ball as well as playing against a defense that won't completely pack the middle.
Its the Maddie-Gioya clashing (of skill sets) that might hold us back from finding our identity in the near future. But we shall see. Maybe if Maddie can get more aggressive at all times and Gioya looks to slow down and involve others more we can hit a nice happy medium that involves both and because then we could really take off. We shall see.
Right now, my key starters are Vivi, Peyton, and Maddie. They do more than just shoot. Their all-around game is significant.
I tend to watch a game about three times within two days, probably a time or two later. I know what the box indicates. I'm looking to see what is actually going on. When we make a run to take control of a game, what happens? When we get into trouble, what is the most effective way to get out of it.
It is interesting if you contrast the Kentucky and Colorado State games. CSU killed us from outside. But, we had a better inside game. We also hit some threes. When we finally broke it open, it was Maddie hitting two-pointers that provided the surge. She took over the short game.
Against Kentucky, we lived and died by the three. We didn't really give the post game much of a chance, even when we had both of their posts on the bench. We were still shooting threes because they left us open and surrounded Vivi or EJ. Vivi and EJ don't know what to do if they are surrounded or get the ball more than about five feet from the rim. We don't seem to have a secondary option like having someone crash the other side of the lane if they are surrounded. Often, they surround them, and their outlet passes are stolen. We never had anyone develop the two-point game.
Kentucky hits some threes. But, Epps' two-pointers kept them in it. In the second half, Vivi missed some cripples that we set up for her, and they began hitting threes. Everyone else on the Kentucky team began to play well. We left them wide open.
But, to the Gioya/Dungee thing. I think that Gioya would be better as a sixth man, used much the same way that Sherri was using T'Ona, to get a charge or energy. She can score quickly. The problem is that she is not a good passer, rarely makes good decisions, and plays rather poor defense. She also commits turnovers off of lazy passes, my pet peeve. If you watch her under the boards, she is always there. But, she seems never to block anyone out. Often,, you see her standing right there for the rebound, and someone comes from ten feet away to take it from her. She isn't active at going after the ball. I see Gioya as a liability to the flow of the offense. She can score. But, she doesn't help the rest of it. We were just standing around hitting threes in the first half. Doesn't work.
Dungee seems to play better defense. I think she is about an inch taller, maybe two. She also seems to have more potential. She is not yet a rebounder for some strange reason. But, the game seems to flow with her on the court. With Peyton, Vivi, Maddie, Chelsea, and T'Ona, we flowed well against CSU. I still have reservations about T'Ona in a set. I prefer having Gabbi in the game. She may be in a shooting slump, but T'Ona is in a permanent shooting slump. I like the flow that Gabbi has.
Maddie had a bad game, pure and simple. I thought her post-game comments after the CSU game trended to scoring early rather than waiting until the third quarter. We do quite well if Maddie scores at least five in the first quarter. It seems to create a flow and get everyone involved. But, we just don't play well with Maddie on the bench. We don't have five players who can coordinate anything.