I don't really think of Amanda, although Sherri does, based on the post-game press conference. I see her as a bit smaller, less of a bruiser, but more mobile, and has a better natural shot. I think she is already a better shot than Amanda eventually became.
Amanda was a PF type, probably would battle Baylor's current duo to a standstill on the boards and not be pushed around at all. But, she had to work to become a scorer, had to develop a shot.
I think Madi is a bit quicker, more mobile, and has a higher ceiling, although probably not under the boards. She'll never be a "power" forward. She will get her rebounds with athleticism and positioning. But, I never saw Amanda as someone who might score thirty every night. Madi may well be someone who could take off for forty.