I know Kuath has already stated he’s out. Sounds like his family could use the support and he doesn’t have any NBA future whatsoever— I also doubt an extra year at OU will significantly impact his overseas prospects.
I view Manek and Reaves differently. Right now, I’d say Manek has zero chance at the NBA. He won’t get drafted; MAYBE he gets a camp invite. But his NBA prospects are very low currently. Coming back for another year could only help him there. Yes, his age would be a turnoff, but let’s say he came back and had a stellar fifth year— it could catch the eyes of NBA people and whatever chance he’d have would likely go up, not down. I don’t know his family situation, but based on what we’ve read over the years, I don’t get the impression they are in dire financial straights. Overseas will be there for him regardless. It’s also such a great time in your life at that age— I think if I’m objectively counseling Manek, I’d advise returning. This assumes of course that he likes it in Norman and would enjoy playing another year.
Reaves is tougher. I think he’s a borderline NBA prospect right now. He can affect the game in multiple ways; but his shooting has deteriorate so much that it has to be a turnoff to anyone scouting him for next level right now. But he’s intriguing. A fifth year for Reaves could do wonders— or it could potentially hurt him if he really doesn’t get better and instead just gets a year older.
My main point would be this— let’s assume these kids love playing college hoops and are enjoying their time in Norman. Also factor in that their last two years have been altered by rona— their experience lessened and limited. Neither is risking much by staying another year. Worst case they don’t improve their NBA prospects— but Europe would still be there. And career ending injures in college basketball are really rare. Very small risk with that. Now, if either or both just WANTED to leave and were done with the college game/scene, then sure, I’d tell them to go do what they want. But if the desire to stay on campus was still there, I don’t think they are risking much at with their futures by staying— probably only increasing odds.