My stock answers to best to not win it all have always been 88 OU, 85 Georgetown, and 91 UNLV. All three of those not winning it all to me are borderline shocking. The 99 Duke team is a good choice too, but I can't say I was "shocked" they didn't win--though I did expect them to win that year.
This is an EXCELLENT thread by the way!
This is an EXCELLENT thread by the way!