Off the top of my head, I can’t think of anyone who redshirted under Moser and eventually contributed. If Luke is the “best” example of a redshirt, it’s a bad sign. The fact Atak is sticking around could either be a sign he thinks he has a shot, or it could be an indication he doesn’t have many options and doesn’t want to drop down a level.
Atak was always going to need to add weight. I hope the S&C was all over him last year so he’s ready to be a spark plug off the bench.