Southern Nazarene is gig step from Hillsdale, but I get your drift. I would imagine a good fraternity team from OU could beat Hillsdale.
I used to ref a high level men's league here in North Houston (Woodlands). Most of the players were ex-NBA or played college ball. The best player in the league was a doctor in the Woodlands, and he played at Southern although it was Bethany Nazarene when he played.