I never understand posts like this one.
We could lay an egg against Cincy, and it needn't necessarily mean squat about the rest of the season. A bad outing is a bad outing, but doesn't necessarily impact the team's performance the rest of the way.
What would be more accurate to say would be, "If we go out and get rolled by Cincy, then many of our fans will jump to the conclusion that we are in for a truly horrendous season. Likewise, if we win or are very competitive, many of those same fans will feel much better about our prospects."
But one early game doesn't make or break a season. It just doesn't. The team's fate won't be written in stone one way or the other, no matter what happens against Cincy.
Only the collective attitude of the fans will be directly impacted.