Let me put this comparison another way. Hield and Hornbeak were rated significantly higher than Booker was/is. Pledger was better than both of them last year. And Cousins. And every OU player not named Osby. But he will be "easily" replaced by a guy with Booker's pedigree? Not going to happen next year.
I think Booker has a chance to be better than Pledger at some point. But it won't be next season.
You sure have an odd way of looking at things. How about this perspective. Buddy and Hornbeak both beat Pledger out last season. Pledger held on to a starting spot in the lineup because he beat out Cam.
You keep saying that Pledger was the 2nd best player on the team. he wasn't, he was the second leading scorer. Just barely. M'Baye was the second best player on the team and any attempt to debate otherwise is foolishness. And just to help a little more with perspective.
OU won 20 games last season and made it to the tourney on Romero Osby's back. Pledger and the rest of them were nothing more than bit players in Romero's show. To try to suggest otherwise is diminishing Osby's season.
Pledger scored 11 points a game and couldn't guard anyone. Hardly the stuff of legends. Pledger, Grooms, and Fitz were nothing more than 2nd rate talents. I'm absolutely confident that by the time they finished up, Kruger was sick of all three of him.
It is no stretch at all to believe that Kruger not only thinks he can easily replace them, he would be happy to do it.
There wasn't a player in the country that was guarded harder than Rotnie Clarke. But, no one worked harder off the ball and it didn't stop him from being a plus 40% career shooter from 3. His defense was adequate and every day, and I mean every day, he stayed late and put up shots till he had 300 makes. Then he had to take a one hour ice bath to keep the soreness at bay.
That is a 1st rate talent.
You look up second rate talent in the dictionary and you find a picture of Pledger. A 37% career shooter from 3. A player who acted like his objective every night was to play an entire game without breaking a sweat. A player that never ever did anything but the bare minimum to get by.
How you wove this Pledger fairy tale in your mind and imprinted on him like a baby duckling does his momma will forever be a mystery.