TMG had already left before Carter committed to the Zags. I think both Poland and Carter were "dirty recruited" away from Oklahoma due to the NCAA stuff and the questions of whether Jeff would return after last season.
If you remember, Jeff was busy recruiting, so he never released a statement or answered questions until signing day was almost here or maybe even after signing day. A bunch of us on this board were wondering why everything was so quiet from Joe and Jeff, and if maybe this meant he wasn't coming back. IMO, this fueled the negative recruiting toward OU and Jeff and cost us Poland and Carter, both of which started on their respective teams.
You throw those 2 guys in with Clark, Davis, Fitz and Pledger and we are at least 4 wins better, maybe more. We would still have a big hole in the middle, but our PG situation is light years better with Carter over Blair.