Exactly. There's a reason why guys like Tiny Gallon and Blake Griffin are 5-star McDonalds all-americans and these no-name 7-foot stiffs are not.
Thats why you take Lebron James and not Darko Milicic.
Sorry, I was too slow. I was supporting DMess saying fool me once, when it comes to overrated 7-footers at Baylor.
I hear you. My point was you can only say one 7 footer has been overrated for Baylor so far and that is Lomers. Big men are always hit or miss. Here's a sampling of 5 star centers from the past 7 years. I bolded the ones who were deserving of a 5 star ranking in hindsight:
2002: Jason Frazer (Villanova);
Amare Stoudemire; Torin Francis (Notre Dame); Paul Davis (Mich St); Deangelo Collins
2003: James Lang; Brian Butch (Wisconsin);
Kendrick Perkins; David Padgett (Kansas)
2004:
Al Jefferson; Randolph Morris (UK); Robert Swift (USC);
Lamarcus Aldridge (UT)
2005:
Andrew Bynum (UConn)
2006:
Greg Oden (Ohio St);
Spencer Hawes (Washington); Brian Zoubek (Duke);
Robin Lopez (Stanford); Jon Kreft; Jason Bennett (KSU)
2007:
Kevin Love (UCLA); DeAndre Jordan (A&M); Kosta Koufos (Ohio St); Solomon Alabi (Florida St); Beas Hamga (UNLV)
2008: BJ Mullens (Ohio St); Ty Walker (Wake Forest); Tony Woods (Wake Forest); J'Mison Morgan (UCLA)
About a 40% success rate in predicting effective centers. A 5 star guy is labeled can't miss coming out of high school and most likely gets a number one pick by some NBA team if college was not an option. So for an apples to apples comparison...
European big men drafted in the 1st round in the last 7 years. I bold the succesful ones:
2002: Nikoloz Tskitishvili (7'0" Denver 5th pick);
Nenad Krstic (6'11" NJ 24th pick)
2003: Darko Milicic (7'0" Detroit 2nd pick); Zarko Cabarkapa (7'0" Phoenix 17th pick)
2004:
Andris Biedrins (6'11" GS 11th pick); Pavel Podkolzin (7'5" Utah 21st pick)
2005: Fran Vazquez (6'10" Orlando 10th pick); Johan Petro (7'0" Seattle 25th pick)
2006:
Andrea Bargnani (6'10" Toronto 1st pick); Oleksiy Pecherov (7'0" Wash 18th pick)
2007: none
2008: Alexis Ajinca (7'0" Charlotte 20th pick)
3 out of 11 of those were successes in my book Krstic (before he got hurt he was a good NBA player); Biedrins and Bargnani.
So your point is well taken. A 5 star US player has a slightly higher success probability than a 5 star rated Euro.