And OU went 1-4 against the teams that didn't, all of which were terrible. What's the point with all this? Are you arguing that season wasn't an unmitigated disaster?
No doubt it was a disaster. From the outside it looked like Capel didn't have control of his team and it imploded from within. The biggest issue of all was the fact Gallon and TMG left and OU ended up getting in trouble for Coach O getting Gallon's mom a short term loan to pay off his tuition so his transcripts could be released. Ended up killing OU's season the next year and recruiting as well.
But, the Big 12 was the best conference in the nation that year and if OU hadn't made the tourney it wouldn't have been a shock, but they should have been at least .500 and IMO at least a bubble team.
Finally, I laugh at the Capel bashers and apologists on this board twisting each and every story/argument to support their agenda.