Forte could start for this OU team over Woodard. Woodard does nothing spectacular. Forte is the better shooter, averages almost twice as many steals per game, averages less turnovers and his assists numbers would go up, if he had better teammates to pass it to.
I'm mixed on your post. I agree with some of it and adamantly disagree with other parts. If Forte were at OU the player he would most likely displace is Woodard .... not Cousins or Buddy. Woodard's overall play has improved a lot this year. His turnovers are down and assists are up. I've seen him make a couple of passes this year that made me rewind my DVR because I couldn't believe he saw the open man (e.g. the pass he made to Spangler on the break for OU's first points against Texas .... Ryan got fouled and hit the FT's so Jordan didn't "officially" get an assist). I think his defense is a lot better, too. He's lost a little weight and I don't see people blowing by him off the dribble like they did at times last year. I commend Jordan for improving his game in a lot of areas this year.
However, Woodard is not a very complete offensive player right now, which makes him the most likely starter on OU to be displaced. He can shoot free throws well in the clutch. He does take the ball inside if a defense goes to sleep. I do agree with DenverSooner when he says PG's are not "expected" to score, but they have to make the defense respect their ability to score and sometimes defenses double up other players and almost dare Jordan to shoot from the perimeter. You can see that he is tentative and doesn't have confidence in his outside shot, but as well as he shoots free throws some of those open 3's are going to start dropping.... he's overdue for a hot streak. He's a lot better offensively than he's shown so far this season. Anyway, I believe that
Here's the deal on Forte: I'm not sure he can play point guard. I know he does an adequate job in order to give Hickey a blow. He doesn't usually guard the other team's quickest and best ball handler. Hickey does. If Forte were on OU and started, it's likely Cousins would play the PG position .... not Forte. While Forte isn't slow and hustles a lot, I'm not sure he has the elite quickness to guard PG's consistently. It's not just about containing someone's point production, but it also means being able to disrupt a PG enough to keep him from getting to a spot and delivering a pass to an open player. A good defensive PG can keep that from happening sometimes and it never shows up in the box score. Those are the kind of intangible things that a Cousins or Woodard or Hickey can do. Maybe Forte can, too, but I haven't watched him that closely defensively..... but he usually guards a 2 or 3 guard who isn't the primary ball handler. The other thing a PG does is look to pass first, and shoot second. They become a facilitator. It's a whole different mindset..... one that both Forte and Cousins might struggle with at times. Dinjyl Walker, too. Woodard and Hickey have that mindset.
This is no knock on Forte.... or Woodard or Cousins. I would love it if he were on the Sooners roster. He would be a welcomed addition primarily for his offensive contributions. He also has a lot of "court sense". A lot of these points are nit-picky personal opinions of mine for the sake of argument. This is an interesting hypothetical discussion, but it's one that nobody can answer or win on a message board. JMHO.