I think you're significantly overrating the impact of Thomas.
He was an important player for us, absolutely.
But he wasn't as good as Osby. And when Osby graduated we went from a 10 seed to a 5 seed.
We also Spangler incoming, emergence of a new era of guards. Woodard was a better PG than the one we had, Hield, Cousins, Hornbeak emerged from solid FR years to big time contributors.
That's why it's important to realize who you have leaving and who you have incoming or emerging.
You can discount Tashawn Thomas impact if you want and maybe we didn't rely very heavily on TT compared to Osby but part of that is because our team offense was relied heavily by Buddy and the guards.
I believe Osbys last year it was Pledge, Mbaye and some freshman guards. Osby shot the ball 330 times in his senior year while TT shot 230 times. Their efficiency's are identical. Osby grabbed more boards but he never played alongside of Spangler who would've taken away some of those from Osby IMO.
We went from a 10 to a 5 mostly because Cousins and Hield went from exciting freshman that could be developed to near all-conference type players in fact Hield I believe was 2nd team?
Plus we had Woodard as a PG instead of Sam Grooms (no offense to Grooms) but that's a big upgrade and we knew that going in.
Looking ahead, I don't think we can reasonably and logically say anyone is going to come close to Tashawn Thomas next year production wise. Maybe the net effect of everyones improvement PLUS the impact from new starter/depth will equal Thomas. There's only so many minutes, possessions, and shots to go around though so its hard for everyone to make a impact. Say Odomes is the best player of the guys who haven't seen the court yet...he won't get the minutes that Manyang Buford or Lattin will simply because there is no way Cousins and Hield don't play 30+mpg.
That only leaves ~ 18 minutes total for the wings (Odomes, James, Booker, Walker, maybe Buford) to share.
Woodard is booked for 25mpg. I don't see a backup PG on our squad either. Walker has been OK but not a PG. Cousins can play it but not like we need.
So we are going to be stacked at the wing position but we won't be able to fully utilize all their talent.
Finding starting PF or C is the important piece.
Maybe someone can show me how Lattin puts up 6/4 next year and Manyang puts up 8 and 6. I think that's a big IF especially when you consider efficiency and their role in the offense. I never once saw Lattin post up in a meaningful game. I don't know a ton about Manyang but all the tape I've seen is of him with putback dunks and little jumpers.
If you watched tight games this year, we were able to go to TT when we needed a bucket and he was pretty good at dishing it out if he was doubled. That's savvy play.
This year Lattin + Thomas = 14/10. I know sometimes they'd be on floor together but TT avg'd 29mpg and Lattin 11mpg so that's 1 full time position statistically.