would put odds they hire gotlib as a reaction to underwood taking off after a year instead of doing a real search....I don't see that ending well
I think the issue becomes, who do they get? If they weren't willing to give Underwood a raise, they aren't going out and getting a good coach because they won't pay. The other issue becomes, who wants to work with Holder? You've seen his issues with Gundy, and now issues with Underwood. Who is going to want to go there besides a dude from a small school?
Gottlieb would energize the fanbase, would be cheap, and would allow you to say "I tried an alum, it didn't work out"
Plus, it would be hilarious if he got the job as an OU fan.