Personally, I think that Taylor could have developed into a stronger player than what Smart may be, but that doesn't mean I think that either will be stars. Your analysis of their skills is pretty good, but I still think we need players like this on our roster. I don't mean to imply that I think either are world beaters, but they both look/looked to be solid guys who could provide value to a university over 4 years. Guys like this are key pieces to the puzzle because they are usually the guys that end up providing fairly steady production and will occassionally have an exceptional game that lifts us over the top when the bigger "star" player(s) aren't performing at their prime. Sure you don't want a team full of these guys, but having one or two guys who show the ability to get in the lane, make a shot, or find the open man (albeit sometimes with less than stellar handles, speed, and in some cases athleticism) is a great asset to have at your disposal.