they used to never say Baylor underachieved... You have to win and raise expectations in order to underachieve. Baylor is like most NCAA programs outside the top 15 programs. They are striving for consistency. Some years they have the pieces and some years they don't.
Next year will have a lot more in common with their 2009-2010 elite 8 team. They will be much better without Dunn but more importantly with the additions of Quincy Miller and Pierre Jackson.
Pierre will be a huge upgrade for them at PG. And Baylor will have the best "finisher" frontcourt in college basketball with Quincy Miller; Perry Jones; Quincy Acy; Anthony Jones; Cory Jefferson and Deuce Bello.