I have refrained on this one even though my strong opinion was that wayman was the right answer. Yesterday I had a chance to ask a coach that was on the staff when tisdale was at ou his opinion. Without hesitation he replied Blake. He went on to say that after a game during Blake's freshman season, wayman said to him, "I wish I could have been as good as that kid"
There has been so many great players in college. Tisdale is one of them. Had Blake left for the NBA after his freshman year, I don't think Blake would go down as one of the top 30 OU basketball players of all time (talking about their performance in college). What Blake did as a sophomore will go down as one of the most dominant performances in the history of college basketball. His athleticism is off the charts scary. Even a knee injury didn't stop him from being the NBA highlight reel his rookie season. And Blake wasn't projected to be 1st team all american that year either.
Tisdale deserved that award b/c he brought it from day one. He was a dominant force from day 1 til his last game.