As much as I like Manek, he's the only one I could see red-shirting.
I think we can all agree that Young, Lattin, James, McGusty, Odomes, Doolittle and McNeace (who already used his redshirt) will not redshirt this season. Freeman won't either because he burned his redshirt in the second semester last year. Shepherd has already proven his worth as our backup point guard, so I think he'll play.
That leaves Lazenby, Polla and Manek as our only candidates. So, why don't we focus on those three for a moment. Is Polla really a legitimate candidate? For one thing he is a unique player due to his size and skill set. Would it be wise to let him watch from the bench the entire season? Not in my opinion. My memory is not as good as it used to be, but I haven't forgotten how our post players were abused by the bigs on other teams last season. Polla is the answer to turning the tide in our favor for a change.
Now, we're down to Lazenby and Manek. Should we burn a shirt on one or both players who impressed me a lot in the first three games of the tour? I wish the answer to that question was as easy as it may appear at first glance, but it's not. Ty and Brady have a chance to be lite scorers who can rack up points from nearly any position on the floor. Can we afford to let them sit this season? Redshirting one or both may depend on if they can defend at this level?
I agree with those that say twelve is too many. I can see Lon going with ten and trimming that number to eight or nine in hard fought, tight games on the road, for example. Ten is doable. Twelve is not. What we have here is a dilemma, sports fans. I've got to admit that I don't have the answer to my own question. I'm just glad Lon and his staff get paid the big bucks to answer it for me.